Sheetz Unveils Fall Milkshakes, Coffees and Treats

The LTO lineup features items including the Pumpkin Pie Milkshake, Pumpkin Cold Foam and Gimme Sh'more Snack Tray.

Aug 19, 2026 | 3 min read

/getContentAsset/119ed11d-a599-4e89-9e17-b522c894620b/e566c176-df54-4c53-982d-4489d9f8132f/Story-2.png?language=en-US

Sheetz is gearing up for the fall season with new seasonal beverages, bakery items and snacks beginning September 2, according to a press release sent to NACS. The LTO menu will be available at all 850-plus Sheetz locations.

Starting off the lineup are new $5 signature milkshake flavors:

  • Pumpkin Pie Milkshake: “Creamy vanilla ice cream blended with dulce and warm pumpkin pie spices which deliver a classic slice-of-pie flavor in every sip.”
  • Pumpkin Cheezecake Milkshake: “A rich vanilla milkshake featuring Philadelphia Cream Cheese cheesecake filling, pumpkin pie spices, whipped cream and graham cracker crumbs.”
  • Cereal Chiller Milkshake: “A nostalgic, fruity rice cereal transforms this vanilla milkshake into a breakfast-inspired dessert that tastes just like Saturday mornings.”

Seasonal coffee offerings at Sheetz include:

  • Pumpkin Chai: “A delicious blend of pumpkin, caramel and warm chai spices makes the newest addition to the Sheetz beverage lineup the ultimate comfort sip. This drink can be enjoyed hot, iced or frozen.” 
  • Pumpkin Cold Foam: “Smooth pumpkin flavor and a hint of caramel come together in new Pumpkin Cold Foam, ready to top any Sheetz Bros Coffee. It's made with protein milk.”
  • Pumpkin Sh’pice Canned Iced Coffee: “Take your fall coffee obsession on the road with Sheetz’s very own Pumpkin Sh’pice Canned Iced Coffee. Packed with pumpkin and warm seasonal spice, it’s perfect for busy mornings or an afternoon pick-me-up. This new canned coffee is available now in the cooler aisle of all stores.”

And in the bakery aisle, the retailer is bringing back its Shweetz Pumpkin Donut Holes and Apple Fritters, plus introducing three new treats:

  • Gimme Sh'more Snack Tray: “Marshmallow fluff topped with mini chocolate chips comes paired with graham sticks for dipping, making it an easy-to-share road trip treat.”
  • Sh’pice Cookie: “Soft, chewy and warmly spiced, this molasses cookie brings a delicious taste of fall to every bite.”
  • Blueberry Açaí Smoothie Cup: “Blends dragonfruit, açaí, blueberries, vanilla Greek yogurt and chia pudding into a protein-packed snack with 15 grams of protein and seven grams of fiber.” 

“Fall at Sheetz should taste as festive as it feels,” said Jacee Scoular, director of brand strategy and design at Sheetz. “Our customers want the pumpkin, spice and comfort they love, but they also expect us to make it bigger, bolder and a little unexpected. From a Pumpkin Cheezecake Milkshake to a Sh’mores snack tray, this lineup is built to turn every Sheetz run into the ultimate stop for fall flavors." 

Earlier this month, Sheetz was named to this year’s "Companies that Care" list by Great Place To Work and People Magazine. Sheetz said this marks the fifth consecutive year, and sixth time in seven years, that it has been ranked on the national list. Sheetz ranks 73rd on this year's list.

NACS serves the global convenience and fuel retailing industry by providing industry knowledge, connections and issues leadership to ensure the competitive viability of its members’ businesses.


© NACS ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy