NEW YORK; PARIS – Consumers are growing increasingly frustrated with a high-street shopping experience that offers little of the convenience of online counterparts, with four in 10 (40%) claiming shopping in-store is a chore and a third (32%) saying they would rather be at home washing the dishes, according to a new report by Capgemini’s Digital Transformation Institute.

“Making the Digital Connection: Why Physical Retail Stores Need a Reboot,” a study of 6,000 consumers and 500 retail executives from the United States, China, Germany, France, the United Kingdom, Italy, Spain, the Netherlands and Sweden, highlights a growing divide between retailers and consumers on the importance of physical stores.

While 81% of retail executives see the store as important, less than half of consumers (45%) agree. Shoppers are frustrated by in-person retail experiences that have not only failed to keep pace with developments in online shopping but are also disconnected from online stores. Dissatisfaction is highest in Sweden and Spain (54% and 49% respectively say bricks and mortar shopping is a chore) and lowest in China and the U.S. (29% and 31% respectively).

More than half (54%) of the retail executives surveyed admit that they have been slow to digitize their physical stores, and consumers’ in-store frustrations are rooted in not having access to features now commonplace on online stores:

• 71% find it difficult to compare products
• 66% are annoyed by long lines at checkout
• 65% complain that the promotions they receive in store aren’t relevant
• 65% simply can’t find the product that they want

Low in-store satisfaction is one of two significant challenges faced by traditional retailers uncovered by the survey. Consumers are also exploring new retail models that reduce their reliance on traditional retailers. More than half are open to buying directly from manufacturers in the future (57%) or buying from technology players such as Google, Apple and Facebook (59%) if they partnered with local retailers for last-mile delivery. Overall, 71% of consumers would consider bypassing traditional retailers, but this attitude is most prevalent in China, where well over three quarters (87%) of respondents would consider alternatives.

Retailers recognize the importance of in-store digitization—it’s a top management priority for most retail executives (78%)—however they are limited by both existing technology investments and the capabilities of in-store staff. Forty-percent of retail executives say that they are still implementing technology foundations, such as in-store Wi-Fi, while a similar number claim that store managers are not promoting in-store digital initiatives. More significantly, 43% say they are unable to measure the return on investment from in-store digital initiatives despite high usage. Overall, only 18% of retail executives have implemented digital initiatives at scale and are generating significant benefits.

“Shoppers are increasingly disconnected with the in-store experience, and it’s easy to see why. Most physical shops remain stubbornly ‘offline,’ unable to offer the speed, flexibility and sheer ease of use that consumers take for granted on websites,” said Mike Petevinos, global head of consumer products and retail at Capgemini Consulting. “Rumors of the death of the high street store may be exaggerated, but they are becoming uncomfortably close to the mark. Many retailers we spoke to admit they aren’t digitizing stores quickly enough because making a business case for investment is challenging. This report makes it clear the real question retailers have to be asking themselves isn’t whether they can afford to transform the in-store experience, but can they afford not to?”

It’s not all doom and gloom for physical retailers. Consumers believe that stores still have a role in their lives, as 70% still want to touch and feel products before they buy. However, they not only expect to see the same features that they find online implemented in-store, but also want more incentives:

• Physical stores need to offer online features: Three quarters of consumers (75%) want to check if stock is available before going in-store, and 73% of consumers expect same day delivery of products purchased in-store.
• Stores need to do more than sell and fulfill: 57% of consumers want retailers to offer more than simply selling the product and for them to provide social spaces, learning experiences and inspiration, such as cooking or DIY workshops.
• Rewarding store visits: Seven out of ten consumers (68%) expect loyalty points for spending time in store and repeat visits, while 61% want store memberships that offer lower prices.

Kees Jacobs, consumer goods and retail lead at Capgemini, said: “Brick and mortar stores of the future will need to be very different if they are to give consumers a reason to leave their computer, abandon their dishes and visit. What is clear from this report though is that they still have a big role to play; the industry is going to see a fascinating struggle take place in the next few years to decide what exactly the new breed of retail store looks like.”

The report is available for download.